What stops banks from lending to energy efficiency projects?

- By:

Courtesy of Energy Efficiency Markets LLC

Four years after the US credit market crashed, energy efficiency projects continue to struggle to secure financing.

What’s the problem? A slow economy, of course. But when it comes to energy efficiency – and on-site renewable energy – the problem runs deeper.

It’s not lack of interest in green energy. To the contrary, says Angela Ferrante, director of alternative energy solutions at Energi, a Massachusetts reinsurance company that provides  insurance and risk management products for the energy industry.

Banks are interested in lending to green projects, in part because of the number of customers now knocking on their doors seeking financing for energy efficiency and solar installations.

“When they hear it from their clients, it is a lot more compelling than hearing about green so and so in the newspaper,” she said.

In addition, banks see energy efficiency as a new market opportunity. Energy efficiency is experiencing rapid growth and strong government support, especially in the pricey energy markets of California and the Northeast.

“Banks are faced with new regulations and they are trying to see what types of products they can diversify into,”  Ferrante said.

But lenders become spooked when they begin to evaluate the risks associated with energy efficiency and on-site solar.

For example, energy efficiency and solar companies often base their sales pitch to the customer on guaranteed energy savings. Many deals are structured so that the customer pays for the energy equipment with money saved on energy bills. What if something goes wrong and the energy savings do not materialize? Will the bank be unable to collect on the loan? And what serves as  collateral? If the loan goes into default, does the bank go into the home, office building or factory and rip out the solar panels, lighting, efficient motors, or insulation? Not likely.

Energi is attempting to “de-risk” green energy projects for lenders and energy developers with new insurance and warranty products. One such product, energy savings warranty insurance, backstops the promised energy savings, even for small contractors and energy service companies (ESCOs).

Larger ESCOs have been able to offer such guarantees on their own because of their size and their clientele, which is often the financially stable ‘MUSH’ market – municipal/university/ schools/hospitals. But it has been difficult for smaller companies and contractors, who serve businesses and homes, to do the same.

Thus, such insurance products could be “game changers,” said Kevin Kaminski, Energi senior vice president of alternative energy solutions. Warranty insurance gives smaller energy companies the ability to offer clients the same kind of favorable terms as the larger players – and the smaller companies can literally take the deals to the bank as a low-risk proposition.

As federal funds and incentives become more scarce, the green energy industry is likely to see more and more innovation in financing like the Energi products. Solar gardens are another example of emerging innovation, as well as real estate investment trusts and master limited partnerships (MLPs), a form now allowed for oil and gas investment, but not renewables.  For more details on solar gardens and MLPs, see my article “US renewables: New financial models” in the November 2012 issue of Platts Energy Economist. For more on green energy and risk, see Energi’s free guidebook, ‘Risk Mitigation for Reference Guild for New Energy Financing.”

Elisa Wood is a long-time energy writer whose free newsletter, Energy Efficiency Markets, is available at RealEnergyWriters.com


Customer comments

  1. By Sid Abma on

    Good day Ms. Wood Have you heard yet about Increasing Natural Gas Energy Efficiency? Natural gas is stated to be the Worlds most important energy source from now til 2050. America has such an abundance of natural gas thanks to the new technology of Hydraulic Fracturing. Natural gas if America plays it's cards right will give America Energy Security and Energy Independence. But that does not mean that we can start Wasting it. America now has to learn that this energy can and must be consumed efficiently, if America wants to continue to have reasonably priced natural gas for a longer period of time. Every natural gas appliance has a chimney, and out of that chimney goes the waste energy. The heat energy that the appliance was not able to "grab". The technology of Condensing Flue Gas Heat Recovery is designed to recover that heat energy from those waste exhaust gases, so that this recovered energy can yet be used back inside the building where it was combusted as space heating or to heat domestic water or for industry their process or plant washdown water. At a hotel or university this recovered energy can even be used to heat the swimming pools. Increased Natural Gas Energy Efficiency = Reduced natural gas bills = Profit Increased Natural Gas Energy Efficiency = Cool Exhaust = Global Warming? Increased Natural Gas Energy Efficiency = Reduced Emissions Increased natural gas energy efficiency with the technology of Condensing flue gas heat recovery means the WATER is even being recovered from these combusted natural gas exhaust gases = Water Conservation What is left to be desired for the environment. And yet our governments and the banks do not yet realize the potential of Increased Natural Gas Energy Efficiency. Any idea why?

  2. By Sid Abma on

    Ms. Wood Something new for you to investigate. It has to do with natural gas, America's clean energy. Today 40%(?) of all the natural gas consumed is wasted, blown up chimneys all across the country as HOT exhaust into the atmosphere. America's commercial buildings and industry and power plants in 2011 consumed approx 17.5 Trillion cu.ft of natural gas. Electricity and solar is important. The technology of Condensing Flue Gas Heat Recovery is designed to recover the heat energy out of these waste natural gas exhaust gases, so that it can still be used back in the building or facility where it was combusted. The goal is to use this energy to well over 90% energy efficiency. Increased natural gas energy efficiency = Reduced utility bills = Profit Increased natural gas energy efficiency = Reduced greenhouse gas emissions Increased natural gas energy efficiency = Water conservation How do we get America to realize the potential of using this energy source efficiently? I look forward to your reply. Sid Abma www.SidelSystems.com (805) 462-1250